Tesla’s 4680 battery technology was meant to revolutionize EVs, yet production challenges have stalled its success. Meanwhile, BMW is betting big on its large cylindrical batteries. But can it succeed where Tesla struggles? And how crucial is thermal management in this race?
Battery technology is more than just higher energy density—thermal management and safety are critical. Heat buildup reduces battery lifespan, impacts charging speed, and can even cause thermal runaway. Efficient cooling solutions, like liquid cooling plates and battery enclosures, are essential for maintaining performance and longevity. Companies specializing in EV battery thermal management, such as XDTHERMAL, provide advanced cooling solutions that help maximize battery efficiency and safety.
To better understand why BMW may succeed where Tesla struggles, we can compare their approaches to large cylindrical batteries:
From this table, it’s clear that BMW’s strategy is more focused on stability, supplier partnerships, and effective thermal management, while Tesla is facing significant production and performance challenges.
Tesla’s 4680 battery packs experience excessive internal heat due to their compact design and lack of advanced cooling solutions. This leads to performance degradation, reduced battery lifespan, and charging limitations, making effective thermal management a critical concern.
Tesla’s CTC (cell-to-chassis) design integrates batteries directly into the car frame, which makes cooling more difficult. Without effective liquid cooling, heat buildup reduces battery performance and safety. This challenge highlights the importance of thermal solutions, a key area where XDTHERMAL’s expertise in liquid cooling plates and enclosures becomes relevant.
Tesla is attempting to refine its battery production to solve heat-related failures. However, experts like CATL’s Chairman question the 4680’s scalability. Without redesigning the cooling system, heat retention will remain a problem, impacting both charging speeds and battery lifespan.
Tesla’s 4680 battery technology struggles with manufacturing inefficiencies and heat retention issues. Without reliable cooling, it is difficult to ensure long-term performance. Companies like BMW are addressing these concerns early, ensuring their batteries will be more stable, scalable, and efficient in real-world applications.
BMW’s New Generation EVs (2025) will use 4695 & 46120 cylindrical cells, featuring 20% higher energy density and 30% faster charging than previous BMW batteries. Unlike Tesla, BMW prioritizes stable wet-coating production, allowing efficient large-scale manufacturing.
BMW’s strategy focuses on supplier collaboration and modular pack design. By working with CATL & EVE Energy, BMW ensures steady battery production. Its Energy Master Battery Management System optimizes thermal stability, increasing battery longevity and efficiency.
BMW’s pack-to-open-body (PTOB) design allows for better liquid cooling integration than Tesla’s CTC approach. Liquid cooling plates, serpentine tubes, and thermal enclosures provide more effective heat dissipation, ensuring consistent battery performance. While Tesla faces overheating challenges, BMW’s focus on thermal efficiency puts it in a stronger position.
BMW’s large cylindrical batteries benefit from better supplier management and superior cooling technology. By optimizing heat dissipation, BMW ensures higher battery efficiency, extended lifespan, and improved safety, positioning itself as a leader in EV battery innovation.
As EV battery densities increase, managing heat efficiently is more critical than ever. Without proper thermal solutions, batteries suffer from faster degradation, limited charge speeds, and safety risks. This is why liquid cooling systems are becoming the industry standard.
Companies like XDTHERMAL specialize in EV battery cooling, offering high-performance liquid cooling plates and thermal enclosures. These enhance heat dissipation, improving battery longevity and safety. Such solutions are becoming indispensable for high-capacity EV batteries.
While air cooling systems are less complex, liquid cooling solutions provide better heat transfer and temperature control. As battery energy density increases, active cooling methods like XDTHERMAL’s vacuum brazing and fluid simulation ensure EV batteries stay cool under extreme conditions, maximizing performance.
Thermal management is critical for EV batteries, ensuring safety, fast charging, and longevity. Companies like XDTHERMAL play a key role in advancing battery cooling solutions, supporting the industry’s push for high-performance, efficient EV technology.
BMW’s focus on modular integration, stable supply chains, and superior thermal management gives it an advantage over Tesla. Better cooling and a collaborative production approach ensure scalability and performance stability.
As EV battery technology advances, efficient cooling systems will be essential to support higher energy densities and charging speeds. Companies specializing in liquid cooling, like XDTHERMAL, continue to develop solutions that will shape the future of EV battery innovation.
BMW’s New Generation EVs, with superior thermal management and supplier-backed production, are set to outperform Tesla’s 4680 struggles. The future of EV batteries depends not just on energy density, but on cooling efficiency
The future of EV battery technology depends not only on energy density but also on efficient cooling and long-term reliability. Advancements in liquid cooling solutions and thermal management systems will be key to ensuring faster charging, enhanced safety, and extended battery life, paving the way for more efficient electric mobility.
EN 
DE 
ES 
KO 